Saturday at three o’clock holds a special place in English football. For generations, it has meant meeting friends, walking towards the ground and spending an afternoon hoping your team makes the journey worthwhile.
But for supporters unable to attend, it can also mean being prevented from watching their own club live. That tension sits at the heart of the debate over whether football’s broadcasting blackout should remain or be abolished.
In England, the restriction generally prevents live football from being shown on television or through domestic video streams between 2.45pm and 5.15pm on designated Saturdays. Its purpose is to protect attendances and participation throughout the game.
The strongest argument for keeping it comes from looking beyond the Premier League.
For EFL and non-league clubs, people coming through the turnstiles bring income that extends beyond admission. Programmes, food, drinks and visits to the clubhouse all contribute. A modest fall in attendance could make a meaningful difference to a club operating on a tight budget.
The concern is particularly understandable in non-league football. A supporter whose main team is playing away might spend Saturday watching a nearby club. A neutral might choose a local fixture because there is no major televised match competing for their attention.
Those occasional visitors matter. Protecting their attendance is a more convincing argument than suggesting a lifelong supporter will suddenly abandon their club because another match is on television.
Non-league grounds also provide opportunities for families to experience affordable football, volunteers to contribute and communities to gather. Supporters of the blackout believe those benefits deserve protection when broadcasting decisions are made.
However, there is a strong argument that the restriction treats people who cannot attend unfairly.
Disability, illness, work, caring responsibilities, distance and the cost of travelling can all prevent supporters from reaching a ground. Removing a viewing option does not remove those obstacles. Someone unable to make a long away trip may simply miss the match altogether.
For those fans, access to a legal broadcast could strengthen their connection with their club. It would allow them to follow the game alongside friends and family, even when attending is impossible.
Abolition could also create opportunities for additional broadcasting income. Yet how that money is distributed would be crucial. A more valuable Premier League television package would not automatically replace lost gate receipts at a non-league ground.
There is a possible benefit for matchgoing supporters too. Allowing games to be televised at 3pm could reduce the pressure to move some fixtures into less convenient slots. That would depend on future broadcasting arrangements, however; removing the blackout would not guarantee an end to awkward kick-off times.
The difficulty is that both sides can become too certain about what would happen.
Healthy crowds do not prove attendances would be unaffected by abolition. Equally, the blackout’s long history does not prove it remains the best way to protect them. The effects could vary considerably between a sold-out stadium and a small club competing for occasional local visitors.
A carefully monitored trial could help establish a clearer picture. It would need to examine attendances, spending inside grounds and the effect on neighbouring clubs, including those outside the EFL. Supporters unable to attend should also have a voice in that assessment.
Any reform should include clear arrangements for sharing additional income and responding if smaller clubs lose out. Keeping the blackout should likewise come with a willingness to review whether it is achieving its purpose.
There is a reasonable case for protecting Saturday afternoons, and a reasonable case for letting more supporters watch. The decision deserves more thought than either defending tradition automatically or assuming another television package will benefit everyone.
Whatever happens, football should try to make Saturdays better for the people who sustain it.
And if every 3pm match eventually reaches our screens, supporters should remember that greater access carries its own risks: there will be absolutely nowhere to hide when your striker puts an unmarked header into Row Z.
Some things, sadly, will remain available in every broadcasting package.